Germany is flat-out waging economic war on its fellow EU countries…
The euro’s persistent strength has been bizarre. It does not make a
lot of sense in light of Europe’s overall challenging economic
conditions. This is partly because the ECB (European Central Bank) is
incompetent. As Mark Blythe has observed, the ECB is not a “real”
central bank. It is actually a currency board in drag, meaning the ECB
can do some of the things a real central bank can do, but not the most
important things.
Furthermore, many assume that a strong currency is a sign of
sensible monetary policy. But this is not always the cause. It is a
misread of macroeconomics, overly focused on surface level
interpretations – like the false idea it is always good to save and cut
back on debt. These things are good in general overall terms, but there
are certain situations where saving and cutting back on debt can
actually shrink the size of your economy, and make your relative debt
load even worse! (Macroeconomics can be weird.)
At any rate, Germany is a country unlike any other in the euro zone.
The German psyche is historically shaped by two things: A passionate
hatred of inflation and a laser-like focus on high-margin exports.
(Think high end industrial equipment, BMWs and Mercedes, chemical
processes and so on. Germany’s export mix is very similar to Japan’s.)
Because Germany is so different from all the other countries in the euro
zone, their solution to the financial crisis – “become more like us, be
more German” – never actually made sense. When Germany tightens its
belt and keeps costs down, this helps the German economy – because lower
costs contribute to price competitiveness, which helps Germany pump out
high-margin exports. But Greece, Spain, Portugal et al don’t have
meaningful exports to speak of.
As Mark Blythe has put it (paraphrase): “What is Greece going to do, start making Audis? And if they did, who would buy them?”
Germany’s low inflation, cost-control economic solutions, in
otherwords, are good for Germany specifically, because the Germans are
so good at exporting. Low inflation is also a key consideration for a
high-margin exporter… because again, it keeps you competitive. But this
medicine is absolutely terrible for all the periphery countries. When
your economy is saddled with an albatross of debt, and you are flirting
with outright deflation – Greece recently posted the most deflationary
numbers since records began, back in 1960 or so – German-style policy
can kill you.
And this is exactly what is happening. The periphery countries are
slowly being killed by creeping deflation and Great-Depression-like
unemployment levels…
So on one level, the strong euro is a function of Germany, as the big
dog in the mix, running monetary policy that is killing the periphery
countries… and the periphery countries simply taking it. “Not our
problem,” the Germans might say. “They shouldn’t have borrowed so much
in the first place.” But do tell, Germany, who lent them all that money
in the first place? And what did the periphery countries do with it? In
large part they bought Audis, BMWs, espresso machines and the like…
things exported by Germans. In sum, one can argue Germany has waged “war
by other means” on its counterparts in the EU via economic dominance
and ill-fit monetary policies. The wealthy Germans lent a ton of money
to the sad-sack peripheries… took the profits when the periphery
countries used that borrowed money to buy a bunch of “stuff” from
Germany (via import imbalance)… and now that the periphery countries are
choking on the debt, Germany owns them, psychologically and fiscally.
It is a good thing the broad masses do not actually understand macro.
If they did, there would be many more riots in the streets. (Europe
already
has rioting in the streets, of course… but if the extent of this were known it would be worse…)
But wait. As Ron Popeil liked to say, that’s not all. Germany is also
waging economic war on the Italians and the French! How so? Because
Italy and France actually have competitive manufacturing industries that
can export. Unfortunately for the Italians and French, however, these
manufacturers are not as competitive as the Germans. Because Italy and
France cannot match Germany, they must charge more to make a widget and
still show a profit. This means that an expensive currency (the euro)
hurts Italy and France’s ability to globally compete. Germany does not
mind a strong euro, however, because it is one of the best in the world
at what it does. Not only can German exporters tolerate a strong euro…
they actually like it, because it lets them take manufacturing business
away from the lesser equipped Italians and French!
We do not hate Germans by any means. (Some on the Mercenary team have
German roots, and we have colleagues and friends in Berlin.) But the
screwed up nature of what is happening in Europe right now nicely
illustrates why ill-thought currency union among a wholly disparate
group of countries, solely for the idealistic political purpose of
avoiding war, was one of the worst ideas ever conceived. Lumping Germany
in with all the others is like having a Friesian draft horse on a
wagon-pulling team with a bunch of Chihuahuas. And whether it does so
intentionally or completely by accident, Germany
really is
waging economic war on its fellow euro-using countries right now, in
ways that will produce dramatic and dire results when things come to a
head.
As Charles Gave of research house Gavekal has pointed out, the euro’s
uncanny strength can be assigned to Germany too in respect to export
foreign exchange impacts. Germany sells a hundred-billion-plus worth of
exports to the world, with most of that inventory sold in dollars (the
currency of international trade). Germany then trades those dollars for
euros (because the Germans have little interest in buying US treasuries,
like the oil exporters or China). That inflow from dollars back to
euros thus pushes the euro higher… which is just fine by Germany,
because it allows yet more manufacturing business to be taken from the
Italians and the French, who get priced out of the game.
First and foremost we look at the world through a pragmatic lens, to
try and spot where money can be made (or where risk is building). But we
are also human beings, and cannot help but note the slow tragedy of
what is unfolding. The toll taken on tens of millions of suffering
Europeans is not an abstract thing. Suicides have spiked in the
periphery countries. Many millions of youth in Greece, Spain and
elsewhere – with youth unemployment levels well above 50 percent – are
despairing of ever having a good job, ever, possibly assigned to menial
labor and/or low value minimum wage type work for the balance of their
lifetimes.
Imagine if that were the fate of your own children – not just to
clean toilets or some such thing, but to do so in a foreign country
where they were looked down on by the locals, because your own country
cannot even offer up service jobs. Again from a broader perspective,
looking beyond trading, this is the stuff that frightening political
uprisings are made of. The ghost of Francisco Franco (a horrible fascist
leader) is already stirring in Spain. The Golden Dawn, a neo-Nazi party
in Greece, is gaining in popularity. And this is perhaps the greatest
irony of all: While the euro was essentially dreamed up to bring Germany
into the fold and head off the prospect of future wars, euro-driven
policies are doing more to raise the prospect of future hot war – by
laying a groundwork of shocking pain and suffering – than anything else
has done.